NEW: AudioEye launches Agentic Audits and SDK MCP
Read moreWhat Screen Reader Users Actually Experience with Overlays
Accessibility overlays can make websites harder for screen reader users, not easier. Three longtime screen reader users we interviewed described lag, overlapping audio, and forms that stopped working. Barriers like these can push people with disabilities to leave a brand for good. Below, we’ll share where screen reader users get stuck on sites with overlays and what actually works for them.
Author: Missy Jensen, Senior Content Strategist: AI Search and Discovery
Published: 11/16/2026
)
Max Ivey, AudioEye A11iance member, was partway through a medical survey when he clicked a button. Within seconds, two voices were talking at once. His screen reader kept reading the page, and the site’s own speech engine started reading it too. Nothing had warned him this would happen or told him to switch anything off. He pushed through a bit longer, but eventually, the echo became too much.
“My device was talking at the same time as theirs,” Max said. “It didn’t tell me to turn off my screen reader, didn’t give me any warning.”
Max’s experience isn’t unusual. We asked three screen reader users, including Max, about their experience with overlays. Below, we’ll share where they got stuck, why some of them walked away from sites, and what makes a website actually work for them.
What We Heard
Every screen reader user’s experience is different, but a few issues can come up when a site uses an overlay:
Slower navigation. Pages may lag, making browsing and checkout feel painfully slow.
Conflicting audio. An overlay’s speech features can talk over the user’s own screen reader.
Unresponsive forms and controls. Radio buttons, checkboxes, and tables may not work as expected.
Inconsistent behavior. An overlay might help on one part of a site and get in the way on another.
How Do Screen Reader Users Know a Site Has an Overlay?
Often, right away. Many overlays announce themselves the moment a page loads or invite visitors to click a button for a “better experience.” What happens next can vary. An overlay may change how a screen reader behaves on one site and work without an issue on another.
“When I land on a homepage and it starts babbling that it uses an overlay, I just groan,” Ana Jacobs, AudioEye A11iance member, said. “I know it’s not going to help, and it very well might make it worse.”
Empish Thomas, AudioEye A11iance member, notices it in how JAWS behaves. “It starts acting a little wonky,” she said. “It’s like it’s blocking JAWS from completing tasks.”
What Happens When Screen Reader Users Try to Complete a Task?
Overlay issues are often most noticeable during common tasks, like filling out forms, shopping, and paying bills. Pages may lag, audio can overlap, and form fields may not respond. In some cases, a user has to turn the overlay on for part of a task and off for the rest.
Here are three real examples from our A11iance members:
For Max, speed was one of the biggest problems. “It’s so bad, it slows navigation even if I turn my screen reader off,” Max said.
Empish’s experience shows how unpredictable this can be. Once she turned the overlay on, the site worked fine. But she couldn’t navigate past the homepage until she did, and there was no way to know that before arriving. When every site behaves differently, users may have to relearn the rules each time.
Do Overlays Make Screen Reader Users Leave a Brand?
They can. Using a screen reader often means every task takes more time and effort, so a website that gets in the way can be an easy reason to go elsewhere. If a site isn’t essential, leaving may be the simplest option. If it’s a bank or a doctor’s office, people may push through, but patience can wear thin.
Ana had a subscription with an apparel site that used an overlay. Browsing was painfully slow, and some parts of the site only worked with the overlay on, while others only worked with it off. She reached out to the company about her experience more than once. “I ended up canceling the subscription altogether because I couldn’t deal with the frustration anymore,” she said.
It can be even more frustrating when a fix doesn’t match the request. Ana once asked a retailer to add product descriptions to their site, and the company replied that it had addressed the problem simply by adding an overlay. “An overlay doesn’t add the product descriptions,” she said. “A person has to do that.” She never ended up making a purchase there.
Empish put it more bluntly: “You want my business, but you don’t want me.”
What Makes a Site Work Well with a Screen Reader?
When a site works well, screen reader users don’t have to think about it. Keyboard shortcuts work as they should, images have descriptions, and buttons and checkboxes are clearly labeled. It’s often clear within seconds, and those are the sites that people come back to.
“If I get to the thing I need to do, just get it done, then I’m happy,” Max said.
For Empish, it often comes down to something as small as a checkbox. On a medical form, she just wanted to jump to the boxes and sign off. “When sites allow me to do that, I get excited,” she said.
A few signs tend to stand out early:
Keyboard shortcuts work. Users can jump straight to headings, links, form fields, and checkboxes without hunting for them.
Images have descriptions. Alt text tells users what’s on the page and shows that someone paid attention to the details.
Buttons and fields are clearly labeled. Each control says what it does, so a screen reader isn’t just announcing “button, button, button.”
Pages load quickly. A fast, stable page is much easier to move through with a screen reader.
The layout stays consistent. Users can come back another day and find things right where they left them.
For Ana, alt text is often the first clue. “If a company is taking the time to put alt text on their images, that tells me they have some understanding and some motivation to get the details right,” she said. “When a site gets that right, coming back is easy. You know exactly where to go, where to find what you want, and just zip through it. It’s just such a good feeling.”
Empish compared it to going to the movies and having someone ask if you need a headset before you say a word. There’s nothing to explain and nothing to advocate for. It’s just done.
)
What Screen Reader Users Want Businesses to Do
Don’t rely on technology alone. Automation can help find common issues at scale (some platforms can even make fixes), but it can’t tell you whether a site actually works for the people using it. That takes people who use assistive technology every day. All three A11iance members made this point.
In practice, that can look like testing with people who rely on screen readers and other assistive technology, researching an accessibility tool before installing it, and keeping a real person available when a customer gets stuck. It also means remembering that people with disabilities aren’t one group with one set of needs. Some use magnification, some rely on audio, and some use both.
“Blind and low vision isn’t monolithic,” Empish said. “We’re not one size fits all.”
Turn First Visits Into Repeat Visits
For all the frustration our A11iance members described, they were just as clear about what keeps them coming back.
Ana told us she’ll keep shopping at sites that work for her, even when she could find something cheaper elsewhere. Empish said a site that just works is soothing at the end of a long day.
“People will shop where they are welcome,” Ana said. “If it’s bad, we’ll drop it. If it’s good, we’re loyal.”
Your site is already telling screen reader users whether they’re welcome. Find out what it’s saying. Run AudioEye’s free Website Accessibility Checker to see where you stand, and let our experts help with the rest.
Frequently Asked Questions
Share Article
)
)
)